Skip to main content

An Uphill Battle for the Ad Agency Alternatives

Forrester Research surveyed both client-side marketers and advertising agencies to measure attitudes toward agency effectiveness. Agencies believe that they play a critical role in marketing success, but marketers now see things very differently.

On aggregate, agencies score a dismal Net Promoter rating of -21 percent. This negative rating is reflected in the market performance of advertising holding companies -- despite sales growth, their earnings per share lag behind the S&P 500 and profit margins are being squeezed.

Despite the poor Net Promoter rating, traditional Ad and PR agencies still wield a great degree of influence in the marketing organization. Although marketers claim they are unwilling to recommend agency services, few believe that alternatives exist. However, marketers clearly need help to reach customers who increasingly tune out their marketing communications.

Advertising agencies started as media placement brokers in the 19th century, and some attempted to evolve into strategic advisers during the 20th Century. That said, shifting patterns in media consumption, driven by technology, now expose major weaknesses in traditional agency skill sets.

Today, agencies must deliver technology -- in addition to creative -- expertise, and many traditional agencies struggle to adapt. In fact, according to the Forrester study, marketers view advertising agencies as the least competent among their service providers to deliver marketing technology.

In the midst of this technology-induced media shift, Forrester believes that marketers realize the legacy agencies have all the wrong things in common:

They lack skills in emerging channels -- Marketers aren't convinced that their agencies can formulate new media strategies, and agencies apparently aren't fully convinced themselves. Huge gaps exist between marketer and agency perceptions of ability to deal with changes in TV, Internet, and consumer generated media.

For some unfortunate firms, their Ad and PR agency blunders have resulted in public embarrassment -- including programs such as Wal-Mart's fake blogs, GM's Chevy Tahoe/Apprentice user-generated ads, and who can forget the "non-viral video" pitch for Subway.

They overstate their role in marketing success -- Almost all agencies (93 percent) believe their contributions drive their client's marketing success, while only 63 percent of marketers feel the same. Both points of view may be correct, but the difference lies in a matter of scope. Agencies must take a realistic perspective of their fractional role in the marketing process, while their clients must orchestrate a broader mix of internal and external inputs to drive sales.

They must be held more accountable for results -- Despite the fact that agencies wield influence over a majority of the marketing budget, a staggering 76 percent of marketers do not measure the return on investment (ROI) of their lead agency relationship. Without measurement, marketers cannot hope to manage and improve performance.

However, Forrester says that marketers must measure the ROI of all marketing investments, not just agency work. As one marketer admitted, "We are only now beginning to measure our return on programs we implement." Moreover, while CFOs are pressuring most corporate departments to squeeze out more costs, CMOs have agencies on retainer that aren't prepared to do the work at hand; but they keep paying them regardless.

Frankly, I believe that the musical-chairs game of "agency reviews" is at the heart of this perpetual fiasco -- apathetic marketers simply recycle the same old big-name agencies over and over, under the belief that no CMO was ever fired for choosing a legacy multinational agency.

On this backdrop, small cutting-edge agencies, talented consultants and independent creative contractors attempt to break through this status quo. Given that the procurement process is based upon subjective criteria, and little or no meaningful measure of performance, it's no wonder that changing the dysfunctional behavior is truly an uphill battle.

Popular posts from this blog

Industrial and Manufacturing Technology Growth

In an evolving era of rapid advancement, market demand for innovative technology in the industrial and manufacturing sectors is skyrocketing. Leaders are recognizing the immense potential of digital transformation and are driving initiatives to integrate technologies into their business operations.  These initiatives aim to enhance efficiency, reduce costs, and ultimately drive growth and competitiveness in an increasingly digital business upward trajectory. The industrial and manufacturing sectors have been the backbone of the Global Networked Economy, contributing $16 trillion in value in 2021. Industrial and Manufacturing Tech Market Development   This growth represents a 20 percent increase from 2020, highlighting the resilience and adaptability of these sectors in the face of unprecedented challenges, according to the latest worldwide market study by ABI Research . The five largest manufacturing verticals -- automotive, computer and electronic, primary metal, food, and machinery -

Rise of AI-Enabled Smart Traffic Management

The demand for smart traffic management systems has grown due to rising urban populations and increasing vehicle ownership. With more people and cars concentrated in cities, problems like traffic congestion, air pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions are pressing issues. Since the early 2000s, government leaders have been exploring ways to leverage advances in IoT connectivity, sensors, artificial intelligence (AI), and data analytics to address these transportation challenges. The concept of a Smart City emerged in the 2010s, with smart mobility and intelligent traffic management as key components.  Smart Traffic Management Market Development Concerns about continued climate change, as well as cost savings from improved traffic flow, have further motivated local government investment in these advanced systems. According to the latest worldwide market study by Juniper Research, they found that by 2028, smart traffic management investment will be up by 75 percent from a 2023 figure of

How Generative AI Will Reshape the Economy

The Global Networked Economy -- a term synonymous with the interconnectedness of businesses, individuals, and governments worldwide -- has undergone a remarkable transformation in 2023. Fueled by the rapid growth of digital technologies and the global internet, this phenomenon has given rise to a worldwide marketplace that has already revolutionized the way we live, work, and play. The impact of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) in 2024 will be equally disruptive to many traditional business leaders. GenAI will also create huge opportunities for the fearless pioneers. Global Networked Economy Market Development The Global Networked Economy's evolution traces back to the advent of the Public Internet. The introduction of eCommerce, social media, and cloud computing has been instrumental in reshaping how businesses operate and engage with their customers. This interconnected ecosystem empowers savvy leaders to access new markets, trim operational costs, enhance commercial e