Skip to main content

Groundswell: a Story About Lost Influence


Has traditional advertising and public relations lost its prior influence on the public? That was the overriding question that the authors of the book "Groundswell: winning in a world transformed by social technologies" left me to consider.

Charlene Li and Josh Bernoff, both of Forrester Research, have written a balanced perspective regarding the implications of social technologies impact within the marketplace. Granted, this is the type of commentary that can be interpreted in several different ways.

That said, as mass-media buyers apply their legacy skills in measuring impressions and imprints, you can't help but wonder if those metrics -- and therefore the results being reported -- have any meaningful relevance or benefit to advertisers.

High Price of Mass-Media Irrelevance


Likewise, when assessing the results of traditional public relations investments, if the vast majority of people that are exposed to the carefully crafted content have learned to disregard the message because the source, the communication style and the delivery medium is considered suspect -- does it matter if anyone is keeping score?

When media analysis captures irrelevant data, how can decision makers validate a return on investment? It's not a rhetorical question. Those spending billions on the radio, television and print media really don't know the answer.

Moreover, while advertising and PR professionals ponder how they are going to rationalize a continuation of the status quo -- and get through just one more account review without being fired by their client -- the collective sphere of industrial-age influence peddling (otherwise known as mass-media marketing) is in turmoil.

Low-Cost Influence of Personal Media

Using technologies like blogs and wikis, discussion forums and online reviews, consumers are taking charge of their own experience and getting what they need -- information, support, ideas, products and bargaining power -- from each other. Moreover, they're growing increasingly immune to the previously effective forms of deceptive corporate influence.

The authors say this phenomenon -- that they call the groundswell -- has created a permanent shift in the way the world works. Li and Bernoff believe that most companies see it as a threat -- to some it's a frontal assault on the very essence of their prior marketing practices.

Clearly, there was a time when the world was a much simpler place to sell inferior products and services, without interference -- when marketing spin could be pumped into the receptive minds of the eager masses. Not so today. Everyone with access to the Internet has the means to expose any and all misdeeds.

An Upside for Conversation and Community

Oh, I nearly forgot, for those few marketers who willingly choose to separate themselves from the past, there is a tremendous upside opportunity to engage customers -- and potential customers -- in an authentic and meaningful dialogue.

Retire your spin-doctors, hop aboard the Cluetrain and join the human conversations already flourishing in online communities of interest. Got it? Or, do you still have questions and concerns? That's OK, apparently you're not alone -- according to Li and Bernoff's research.

Popular posts from this blog

Software-Defined Infrastructure: The Platform of Choice

As more organizations adapt to a hybrid working model for their distributed workforce, enterprise CIOs and CTOs are tasked with delivering new productivity-enabling applications, while also seeking ways to effectively reduce IT cost, complexity, and risk. Traditional IT hardware infrastructure is evolving to more software-based solutions. The worldwide software-defined infrastructure (SDI) combined software market reached $12.17 billion during 2020 -- that's an increase of 5 percent over 2019, according to the latest market study by International Data Corporation (IDC). The market grew faster than other core IT technologies. The three technology pillars within the SDI market are: software-defined compute (53 percent of market value), software-defined storage controller (36 percent), and software-defined networking (11 percent). "Software-defined infrastructure solutions have long been popular for companies looking to eliminate cost, complexity, and risk within their data cente

Digital Identity Verification Market to Reach $16.7B

As more enterprise organizations embrace the ongoing transition to digital business transformation, CIOs and CTOs are adopting new technologies that enable the secure identification of individuals within their key stakeholder communities. A "digital identity" is a unique representation of a person. It enables individuals to prove their physical identity during transactions. Moreover, a digital identity is a set of validated digital attributes and credentials for online interactions -- similar to a person's identity within the physical world. Individuals can use a 'digital ID' to be verified through an authorized digital channel. Usually issued or regulated by a national ID scheme, a digital identity serves to identify a unique person online or offline. Digital Identity Systems Market Development Complementary to more traditional forms of identification, digital identity verification systems can enhance the authenticity, security, confidentiality, and efficiency of

Global Pandemic Accelerates the Evolution of Transportation

Given the current trends across the globe, organizations that depend upon the continued growth of personal vehicle ownership will need to consider a plan-B scenario. While some companies will be able to adapt, others may find that their traditional business model has been totally disrupted. According to the latest worldwide market study by Juniper Research, Mobility-as-a-Service (MaaS) will displace over 2.2 billion private car journeys by 2025 -- that's rising from 471 million in 2021. Juniper believes that for MaaS to enjoy widespread adoption, subscription or on-the-go packages need to offer a strong combination of transport modes along with feasible infrastructure changes, high potential for data collection and low barriers to MaaS deployments. Mobility-as-a-Service Market Development The concept of MaaS involves the provision of multi-modal end-to-end travel services through a single platform by which users can determine the best route and price according to real-time traffic