Skip to main content

SXSW 2010: Free-Market for Earned Media


My big take-away from the South-by-Southwest (SXSW) Interactive festival this year was a further validation that big media companies -- traditional publishers of print content in particular -- are still searching for a way to halt their collective slide into eventual insolvency.

Surely, given their vast resources, the very best big publishers are capable of evolving their business model. At least, that's their hope for the future. But, how does an innovation-challenged organization avoid extinction when unrelenting disruption of the prior status-quo continues to erode their once dominant market position?

As I attended the various panels related to this topic, I was reminded of the book "Inside Project Red Stripe" by Andrew Carey -- the story of how six of The Economist's cleverest people tried to create the "next big thing" online and essentially failed, after investing six months in idea exploration.

Hope in the Trust Economy

Big media companies seem to now be clinging to the belief that their fate is somewhat contingent upon the perceived value of an established reputation -- as an example; they're a trusted-source of quality content that you won't find anywhere else.

The rationale goes something like this -- as long as they can perpetuate the facade of their unique trustworthiness, then they still have a fighting chance of competitive survival in the 21st Century.

That said, when looking for a viable solution to their numerous problems, self reflection on past strategic blunders doesn't appear to be under serious consideration. A case in point: the industry insiders still maintain (in denial) that their worsening situation is the fault of others, not theirs.

Craigslist is to blame for the loss of classified advertising revenue. Google is to blame for aggregating newspaper content, grouping it with non-traditional publishers and thereby confusing readers. Bloggers are to blame for producing good-enough quality content, combined with low-price advertising rates. The list of excuses goes on and on.

Competing with Amateurs isn't Easy

In the panel entitled "Media Armageddon: What Happens when The New York Times Dies?" we heard a New York Times employee lament how "professional" reporters are totally frustrated at being scooped by more agile bloggers who tend to publish the story long before the journalist is ready. Others on the panel made consoling comments about the unfair advantages of amateurs.

Ironically, the New York Times has had to deal with several setbacks that eroded trust in the organization's editorial staff -- one of the most recent being accusations of plagiarizing content.

In the panel entitled "Crowd Control: Changing the Face of Media, or Hype" an employee at CNN insisted that investigative reporting was alive and well at big media companies, even after the perpetual newsroom staff cuts. Others on the panel shared their thoughts about how complete and accurate new event coverage typically came only from the established news networks.

Yet, CNN was happy to report (after fact-checking?) on the existence of weapons of mass destruction, when there weren't any found in Iraq. Meanwhile, they neglected to report on Iraqi civilian casualties as a result of the many U.S. air raids during the initial invasion and occupation of Iraq.

Is that why some people say they now watch The Daily Show with Jon Stewart on Comedy Central for the most unfiltered news from around the world? Has news parody become the only remaining path to truth-in-reporting on network TV?

Earned Media in the Free Market

My favorite commentary at SXSW was the notion that perhaps the average American consumer is too stupid to know what quality research and news reporting looks like -- therefore, more people now read independent blogs.

Yes, that's right, it's the customer's fault -- they are to blame as well.

In reality, there's a growing free-market for trust in 2010 and there's also enough thinking people in America to sustain this market transition for a very long time -- if that's what it takes.

Thoughtful trust must be earned -- it's no longer implied by a mere legacy brand. You can't easily regain misplaced trust, it's worthless when you try to buy it, it's pointless to try and fake it. Those who truly are worthy of people's trust will have to compete with a multitude of others who have already proven to be equally or more deserving.

This, I believe, is a sign of much needed progress.

Update: most brands are inherently overvalued by their creators, when moving into a market adjacency scenario. Here's a case in point. Western Union thought they would be a major player in the e-mail services market, based on their legacy brand -- as a trusted provider of telex and cablegrams. However, they failed to fully understand the new medium, and they eventually shuttered their email business after a few years of deep financial losses.

Popular posts from this blog

Digital Talent Demand Exceeds Supply in Asia-Pac

Even the savviest CEO's desire for a digital transformation advantage has to face the global market reality -- there simply isn't enough skilled and experienced talent available to meet demand. According to the latest market study by IDC, around 60-80 percent of Asia-Pacific (AP) organizations find it "difficult" or "extremely difficult" to fill many IT roles -- including cybersecurity, software development, and data insight professionals. Major consequences of the skills shortage are increased workload on remaining digital business and IT employees, increased security risks, and loss of "hard-to-replace" critical transformation knowledge. Digital Business Talent Market Development Although big tech companies' layoffs are making headlines, they are not representative of the overall global marketplace. Ongoing difficulty to fill key practitioner vacancies is still among the top issues faced by leaders across industries. "Skills are difficul

How Cloud Fuels Digital Business Transformation

Across the globe, many CEOs invested in initiatives to expand their digital offerings. User experience enhancements that are enabled by business technology were a priority in many industries. Worldwide end-user spending on public cloud services is forecast to grow 21.7 percent to a total of $597.3 billion in 2023 -- that's up from $491 billion in 2022, according to the latest market study by Gartner. Cloud computing is driving the next phase of digital transformation, as organizations pursue disruption through technologies like generative Artificial Intelligence (AI), Web3, and enterprise Metaverse. Public Cloud Computing Market Development "Hyperscale cloud providers are driving the cloud agenda," said Sid Nag, vice president at Gartner . Organizations view cloud computing as a highly strategic platform for digital transformation initiatives, which requires providers to offer new capabilities as the competition for digital business escalates. "For example, generativ

Mobile Device Market Still Awaiting Recovery

The mobile devices market has experienced three years of unpredictable demand. The global pandemic, geopolitical pressures, supply chain issues, and macroeconomic headwinds have hindered the sector's consistent growth potential. This extremely challenging environment has dramatically affected both demand and supply chains. It has led to subsequent inflationary pressures, leading to a worsening global cost of living crisis suppressing growth and confidence in the sector. In tandem, mobile device industry stakeholders have become more cautious triggering market uncertainties. Mobile Device Market Development Operating under such a backdrop, the development of mobile device ecosystems and vendor landscapes have been impacted severely. Many of these market pressures persisted throughout 2022 and now into 2023, borne chiefly by the smartphone market. According to the latest worldwide market study by ABI Research, worldwide smartphone shipments in 2022 declined 9.6 percent Year-over-Year